February 10, 2004

I Want My MTV (back)

Scott Ott of Scrappleface fame has launched BoycottMTV. Scott’s motivation is based on his belief that

MTV's slick productions promote sexual promiscuity, infidelity, domestic violence, sexism, and racism. And the audience for all of this, quite intentionally, is children. Your child, your grandchild, your niece, your nephew, the students in your classroom, the boy or girl next door, the teen you hire to babysit your children...”

He has a point. Scott’s not asking for outright censorship, merely a boycott of their morally corrupt product. Of course the core issue here (as usual when it comes to talk of censorship) is parenting, but that’s another post for another day…

Discussing this with GF this morning, we were trying to identify what really happened with MTV. Remember when it was cool? Remember “Friday Night Videos?” (those of us who grew up without cable had to settle for that!) I’m not sure if anyone can identify exactly when it happened, but MTV “jumped the shark” when videos slowly lost favor to regular programming. And interestingly enough, somewhere along the way new music started to suck too.

Before you get too upset, I’m not making a blanket statement that ALL new music sucks, just the large majority of it. And I think most people agree – why else are there so many “classic” rock stations repeating the same tired old Steve Miller Band tunes? The music stores are full of digitally re-mastered albums that were originally released 30 years ago. Even the Beatles are still releasing new albums and John & George are gone! Even Disco, one of the most universally hated genres of all time, made a comeback – how else would you explain the Village People’s continued popularity? (Don’t even for a minute tell me you don’t know the Y-M-C-A dance/thingy whatever.)

So, just to recap, MTV sucks. And most new music sucks. Is there a relationship? Maybe not a direct relationship, but I do believe there is a connection. Unfortunately, that’s another post.

Posted by Clancy at February 10, 2004 10:50 AM
Comments
Comments consisting of advertisements are subject to a $100 per comment fee for ad placement. Posting constitutes acceptance of these conditions.

I'm not a fan of censorship and boycotts, really. If you don't like the station, then don't subscribe to the channel. However, I do agree with the fact that MTV has indeed, recently, been sucking. I mean-when is the last time you turned on MTV and actually saw a video? I mean, real music?

Sad. It's become so that I will turn on VH1 while cleaning house, so that the music is there. MTV should learn from that.

Posted by: Helen at February 10, 2004 10:56 AM

And when I say "real music", I am not referring to the basically naked females and males that can't carry a tune. I mean music.

Ohmigod-I sound so old and crotchety!

Posted by: Helen at February 10, 2004 10:57 AM

My rants on the music industry make me feel old and crotchety too!

GF and I spent Saturday relaxing and unwinding from the week at home doing some occasional cleaning, napping and reading. All day long, the tv was tuned to one channel - VH1 classics...

Posted by: Clancy at February 10, 2004 12:04 PM

Listen, I'm 18 and i love the old as well as i love the new, but you have to really listen to what the music is saying. Have you even sat down to really listen to the lyrics of your precious old as well as our "censored" new??? It pretty much reflects on the same thing, but we are just speaking 2 different languages. we all speak of love, drugs, sex, and other things. don't believe me my fav. song is "yellow submarine" by the Beatles and that was about drugs, and i really enJoy listening to "purple pills" by D-12 with Eminem, so before you go about saying how everything sucks, do a refresh on what is old and then listen to the new, i'm sure you will find something similiar!!

Posted by: Joy at March 9, 2004 3:21 PM

and another thing if you haven't notice that VH1 plays almost the same exact thing that MTV plays! i'm not downing you, i'm just speaking my mind!

Posted by: Joy at March 9, 2004 3:24 PM

Joy,

I'm convinced I've just gotten old. You'll understand in about 15 years, trust me....

Posted by: Clancy at March 9, 2004 5:23 PM